Wendell Berry details the fictional life of Jayber Crow beginning with his early losses and search for a home. During his stay at an orphanage, the twelve-year-old interned with the on-site barber and wrestled with the invitation from itinerant preachers to follow God’s call to ministry. Jayber admits (to himself) that he likes the idea of being educated, living on a street with shade trees, receiving the admiration of his community, spending leisurely time reading, and most of all, marrying a young woman. He likes the preacher’s life. He decided he was called, only to change his mind later during seminary. It set him on an adventure to find his life’s work.
Berry is an observational genius and clever writer. He captures a common struggle: how do we know what God is calling us to do?
Two qualifications before the list. First, I am not referring to the general calling to follow Jesus; live a holy life; live by faith. God clearly and repeatedly calls people to these things in Scripture. The challenge relates to what the Puritans named ‘particular callings,’ or what Martin Luther earlier described as ‘spiritual callings.’ These callings entail the idea that an individual has an assignment from God at a specific time.
Second, various church traditions use the term vocation, from the Latin root vocatio – to call or summon. Vocations come with all the accoutrements of gifting, deep joy, opportunity, and validation by a community. In other words, God gifts a person; the individual senses God’s direction; those around recognize the fit; and people are served when the call is answered. While further nuance can be helpful, I will use calling and vocation interchangeably in this article.
You might know someone confused or discerning God’s call like young Jayber. Below are eight common misunderstandings that flow from seasons in my own journey.
Misunderstanding 1
God only calls people to become a priest (or pastor). This was one of the great Reformation fights. Luther was famous for emphasizing God’s providence by saying, “God is milking the cows through the vocation of the milkmaid.” God engineered creation to include human mediation, which means each person receives gifts and responsibilities, or a vocation. Luther also insisted that the milkmaid and farmer (today’s tech and pharmaceutical rep) were doing ministry just like the preacher. God’s calling invites more than the priests to serve.
Misunderstanding 2
God only calls people with an audible voice. This might seem rather elementary to you, but I was one of those people who thought only Moses and Samuel and Isaiah had callings because they heard directly from God. A more sophisticated version of this same misunderstanding is the ‘still small voice.’ Some of us assume that if we haven’t had a special moment (loud or quiet), we don’t have a calling. The full picture of calling includes the ordinary means of prayer, conversations within community, experiences of joy, and affirmation of our daily work. These non-special moments often reveal God’s assignment in our lives.
Misunderstanding 3
God only calls the righteous. Many people in our churches assume, “I’m not good enough at the Christian life for my phone to ring.” You might think you are not on the varsity squad, or that you didn’t even receive an invite to the tryouts. Matthew 9:13 reminds us Jesus did not come to call the righteous but the sick. If this is true about salvation, I argue it is equally true about who gets to do God’s work in all spheres of society. Come as you are—with all your past—recognizing the stewardship you have received.
Misunderstanding 4
God’s calling only implicates salvation, not creation. Arguably, this could have been the first point. If it’s true that the only Christian category for calling is salvation, this list of misunderstandings is irrelevant. Now, it is true (and important) to note the Bible primarily talks about ‘calling’ as a call to Christ. God calls to salvation, hope, repentance, feasting, fasting, fellowship, forgiveness, … to follow him. (Mk. 1:16-20; Acts 2:39; I Cor 1:26; I Cor 7:7-14; 2 Tim 1:9, etc). Still, formative passages like Gen. 1:27-28; Ex. 20:9; I Pet 4:7-11 emphasize the call of God on all humans to take responsibility to tend and cultivate the world. Work remains God’s good idea.
Misunderstanding 5
God’s calling only means career. When teachers or business leaders emphasize God’s call to ‘normal work’, we subtly infer compensation. Work equals what we are paid to do. Thankfully, people like Tom Nelson and others have properly reframed work as contribution, not simply compensation. This validates those working in unpaid care roles for young children, physically disabled, or aging parents. It also implicates those who are ‘retired’ or in a life stage where finances are no longer a primary consideration. God has providentially placed us in specific relationships, roles, and responsibilities for specific seasons. Don’t look past those arenas for a calling.
(The first five misunderstandings are largely fostered in church contexts; at least they were for me. The final three misunderstandings grow out of a modern secular influence.)
Misunderstanding 6
Calling is another form of self-actualization. In 1990, Lee Hardy simplified the cultural taxonomy of sociologist Robert Bellah by describing two ways people find meaning and purpose [1]. First, the Utilitarian Individualists are those success-driven, outcome-oriented climbers who locate the meaning of life in the world of work. They often sacrifice private life or family for the sake of career advancement. Conversely, Expressivist Individualists turn away from the world of work to their private lives for meaning and fulfillment. They maintain escapist instincts. They have bowed out of the rat race and turned to either relationships or leisure activities/experiences to find meaning. Hardy (and Bellah) show how both are twists on the Christian vision of work as a call to serve the common good. Work is not primarily intended to fulfill one’s inner drives. Christians will regularly resist both impulses.
Misunderstanding 7
Culture requires you to leave faith at home. The modern secular workplace discourages, or downright denies, the role of faith in one’s work. The ‘wall of separation’ between church and state was intended to be one-sided. The American founders established this clause to guard the state from coercing religious belief. The First Amendment was never intended to discount what is central to one’s life and values. The marketplace adapted this misunderstanding and has built a sturdy, two-sided wall. The result is an entirely privatized faith, which distorts calling. People are left looking for volunteer roles or church-only callings because it has become impossible to imagine a rich faith integrated into a weekday ‘job’. Vocation should not be limited to private spaces.
Misunderstanding 8
Vocation means ‘You are what you do.” This is not just a modern secular idea. Most people’s identity was so tied to their work that they added surnames like Miller, Fisher, Baker, or Semiconductor-Chipmaker (maybe not the last one). People become so identified with work that when it goes missing through job loss, sickness, or retirement, they are disoriented. They are nameless. In one sense, there is a right aspect to this; if we are created to work and that work is taken away, it is worth lamenting. In another sense, Christians always work from their name, ‘my beloved son or daughter’, not for their name. This moves us to a final comment on calling.
Os Guinness, who set many people on a journey to rightly understand God’s call, helps frame this discussion by considering the first calling to be a child of God. He writes:
First and foremost, we are called to someone (God), not to something (such as motherhood, politics, or teaching) or to somewhere (such as the inner city or Outer Mongolia). Our secondary calling, considering who God is as sovereign, is that everyone everywhere, and in everything, should think, speak, live, and act entirely for him. We can therefore properly say as a matter of secondary calling that we are called to homemaking or to law or to the practice of art history. But these and other things are always the secondary, never the primary calling. They are ‘callings’ rather than the ‘calling.’ They are our personal answer to God’s address, our response to God’s summons. Secondary calling matters, but only because primary calling matters most [2].
Jayber Crow eventually became a barber. Wendell Berry celebrated this simple work done in the town of Port William. God does too.
Editor’s Note: A version of this article was originally published in Lakelight Monthly.
- Lee Hardy, The Fabric of This World: Inquiries into Calling, Career Choice, and the Design of Human Work. Eerdmans, 1990.
- Os Guinness, The Call: Finding and Fulfilling the Central Purpose of Your Life. (Nashville: 2003), 31.

